Friday, March 21, 2008

Challenges Veracity of F & M Letter to Intell / New Era

Nancy Collins, Franklin & Marshall Vice President for Communications, in a letter published Mar. 15 in the Intelligencer Journal/Lancaster New Era, charged that a Mar. 8 column by New Era columnist Carol Petersen ("F&M's what's-good-for-us-is-good-for-you concept") contained "a number of inaccuracies."

One of these "inaccuracies" that Ms. Collins attempts to correct has to do with the Norfolk Southern Dillerville Rail Yard project. Ms. Collins writes that this "project would extend the yard approximately one-eighth of a mile westward along the rail line." Ms. Collins added, "This project provides operational capacity for Norfolk Southern but will not change the types of products handled in the Dillerville yard nor the train schedules."

Doesn't Ms. Collins know that the railroad's switching yard will be moved from its present location in F&M's North Campus to a tract of land in proximity to Long's Park and several up-scale residential neighborhoods in the Farmingdale Road area?

The purpose, said F&M spokesperson Keith Orris at a public meeting on Feb. 19, 2007, that was covered in the Intelligencer Journal on Feb. 20 ("Land swap draws fire," Lori van Ingen) is to "give the college a place to relocate its athletic campus."

This planned "land swap" will result in the switching yard being only a football field's length away from a number of well-maintained and expensive homes. These homeowners have valid concerns regarding increased noise and pollution and a very likely drop in property values.

Mr. Orris was also quoted in that story as saying that the "residents won't be able to stop the railroad from expanding" and promised that F&M would build "sound walls." The same news story quotes a Manheim Twp. resident as saying that the "sound walls" would cause the sound to carry "over the walls" into East Hempfield.

The story stated that residents said that they wanted to talk to the railroad before the design phase, but Keith Orris responded: "Design and engineering will take place through the beginning of 2008 before the plan will be brought to government officials and the public." This means that the residents would only be allowed to comment on a plan that had already been finalized in agreement by F&M and Norfolk Southern Railroad.

In her letter-to-the-editor, Ms. Collins said that Ms. Petersen should have "attempted to learn how these projects could benefit Lancaster before expressing an opinion publicly." Doesn't Ms. Collins know that this project is not in Lancaster or even Lancaster Township? According to the Feb. 20 New Era story quoted above, the land swap would be "entirely within Manheim Township." Since the switching yard is being placed near several housing developments, how can this possibly benefit those homeowners?

Ms. Collins concludes her letter by saying, "We urge the New Era to hold its columnists to the same journalistic standards as it does its news writers, including checking facts, staying informed and adhering to professional standards when conducting interviews." But her letter, which criticizes Ms. Petersen for other "inaccuracies" as well, exhibits a decided lack of factual information. It is as short on facts as it is long on rhetoric.

Monday, March 17, 2008

Challenges F & M's promise re School Lane Hills

This is a perfect example of the hedged, nuanced speech the college always uses. You will notice there is NOT an absolute guarantee. The included paragraph about local zoning etc. is the Catch-22. Our understanding is that Manheim Township requires TWO roads into/out of any development, especially cluster type dwellings. Our understanding is that they cannot just have one entry/exit from Harrisburg Pike only. SO, when the whole Wilson Dr. things gets advanced, F&M will disingenuously respond, "WE aren't pursuing it! The DEVELOPER is," or, "The Township is making this a necessity. Our hands are tied!"

Your headline is wrong. The college has PROMISED nothing. For now, it is not something they will pursue. However, (wink, wink) "we will need to comply with all local ordinances etc etc etc" So, it will be THEIR fault, not F&Ms. HOW CONVENIENT.

Challenge the college to put in writing that should Manheim Township REQUIRE a second entrance/exit from their Baker fields development, it ABSOLUTELY WILL NOT BE THROUGH SCHOOL LANE HILLS, and that if Wilson Drive extension is an absolute necessity, they will abandon development plans. THAT, my friend, would justify your headline of an F&M PROMISE. There is NO PROMISE in what I have read here.

Thursday, March 13, 2008

NewsLanc obstructing City revitalization

Why does your organization do everything in its power to destroy the momentum of the revitalization of the city that is occurring? I live in the city and own my home. I am all for the convention center , First Friday, the ball park and the initiatives of the JSID and FM contributions to making Lancaster city a better and safer place to live.

Projects like the convention center capitalize on the campaign to bring more people and business into the city. The economy of our city needs more folks coming in to town and not leaving the city or only visiting the city for work.

We have so much in this little town to share and I don't understand why your organization is so bent against promoting business, home ownership and job creation downtown.


Editor's response: NewsLanc shares the writer's desire to promote business, home ownership and job creation downtown. We accept as a fact and will help support the convention center. But we don't want to allow Penn Square Partners to unfairly profiteer through questionable clauses in contracts that divert as much as $10 million from the taxpayer supported convention center to the privately-owned hotel .

Press smeared school's name

I am writing about that horrendous auto accident on Route 30 in which three men were killed by an impaired young woman. Certainly, that is a tragic event that will forever change the lives of the families involved. What struck me is why the Lancaster Newspapers had to smear the name of the school that the young woman attended years before, as if the school had something to do with her recent behavior. I wonder why the media persists in that kind of yellow journalism!

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

News article or cheerleading?

[Concerning "Penn Square project rising above Watt & Shand facade" that appeared March 10 in the Lancaster New Era.]

Embarrassing. Again. I bet my dog that the bulk of this was drafted in the P.R. department of one of Dale High's companies. Peel off Bernie Harris' suit and you'll find a cheerleader's uniform, poms, poms under the desk.

Sis, boom, bahhhhh.

Monday, March 10, 2008

Editorial a veiled threat?

The Intelligencer Journal / New Era editorial "The right side" of March 8th concludes: "But we would urge [NewsLanc publisher Robert Field] to consider another piece of Voltaire's wisdom: 'I am very fond of truth, but not at all of martyrdom'.'' Voltaire seems to say, "I seek the truth, but I am willing to recant in the face of danger." That is the meaning in the context of the article.

One assumes that with a WRITTEN essay (as opposed to an impromptu spoken statement) that the intent is carefully thought through.It would seem that they are saying that you are successfully seeking "truth" but that you should stop when your are threatened for expressing the same truth. The only one who would threaten you would be someone who does not want the truth to be known (and are capable of inducing harm)...therefore, since they offer the quote, they either know who could threaten you, or they would threaten you themselves.The instant I read it, it seemed to be a threat. Congratulations for continuing to make the news.

Editor's note: Although several persons interpreted the conclusion of the editorial as a threat, we do not believe it was so meant. NewsLanc appreciates the Intell and New Era's standing up in solidarity for freedom of the press and continuation of the traditional enlightened openness that Rotary International and its Lancaster chapter have demonstrated over the decades.

They are most welcome!

You have no idea how we in Lancaster County are being observed. Residents who have moved out, residents moving in... it is amazing how informed they are to the happenings. NewsLanc and its staff are given credit and thank you's.