Saturday, March 8, 2008

Intell / New Era hit a double

The editorial in today's paper ("The Right Side") proves too things: the established press does follow your postings on your website, and can, on occasion, get up the courage or whatever it is, to back your position. Congratulations! You are right - you do have an impact.

But I was even more surprised with Carol Petersen's column "F&M's what's-good-for-us-is-good-for-you concept" column. This is what a lot of people have been saying for years, but finally it made its way into print - in a combined paper, at that.

F&M's goal: "To Transform Lancaster City"

(Letter from "concerned citizen" courtesy of Looking at Lancaster)


JOHN FRY'S GOAL: TO TRANSFORM LANCASTER CITY INTO "A VIBRANT COLLEGE TOWN"

John Fry, several months prior to his inauguration as president of Franklin and Marshall College, presented his vision for transforming Lancaster into a "vibrant College town" in a 38-page paper titled, "F&M College Strategic Planning White Paper." This paper, dated January 27, 2003, lists his name as the sole author. It became the foundation of the "Campus Master Plan 2004", which uses much of the same terminology.

The White Paper contains statements that define President Fry's view of the relationship between the College and the City. Some of these statements suggest the appropriation of certain public services that are the responsibility of City department heads. The result of this, even if well intended, is the blurring of the distinctions between public property and private property, also civic vs. private suzerainty. The question, in time, becomes, "Who does what and who is in charge of whom?"

An example of this blurring is seen in "Goal II - Strengthen the Campus Community". Under "Strategies - E", is an item that reads: "Ensure that the campus and its surrounding neighborhood and park are vibrant, safe and clean places." Under that heading is this statement: "Through skillful security and police protection, lighting, landscaping, communication devices, electronic security... we can make our campus and surrounding neighborhoods a better environment for all..."

Both the park and the surrounding neighborhood (with the exception of some college-owned properties on College Ave. and Race Ave.) are city property. Citizens ask: why should John Fry be making plans for public property? And especially since the College pays no money to the city in lieu-of-taxes, whereas the city homeowners see their school and city real estate taxes rise every year?


Under "Strategy A - Enhance Public Safety throughout the area", Fry lists some of the services to the City that the College will be providing: "bicycle patrols, street cleaning, tree-trimming and graffiti removal; streetscape management, with specific attention being paid to landlords ... marketing the area as a great place to live ... lighting, signage, street furniture, traffic calming and the like."

Why should F&M be making decisions for the city on traffic calming projects on streets that are city (public) streets - not campus streets? Shouldn't the city traffic engineer be doing this? F&M's first traffic calming project was the "bumped-out curbs" and traffic table on College Ave. that caused a dangerous situation for vehicles and pedestrians, resulting in at least one accident and several reported near accidents. The College Ave. homeowners were neither given advance information about this project, nor an opportunity to comment on it.

There was also an attempt to by-pass neighborhood input and approval with the traffic calming project on Race Ave.: F&M tried to get City approval for this project BEFORE any Race Ave. resident was told that the College wanted to make major and permanent changes to their street – where a sizable number of these homeowners have lived for 30 to 60 years. And the Harrisburg Pike median strip was built, even though a petition by citizens opposing the median strip, citing safety concerns, was sent to PennDOT and to City officials.

Of special interest in Fry's "White Paper" is the section titled "GOAL III - DEEPEN AND ENRICH THE COLLEGE'S TIES TO LANCASTER CITY". A statement that illustrates Fry's mind-set is: "First, the fortunes of Lancaster and Franklin & Marshall are inextricably bound ... the better known and more highly regarded the College is, the better off the City will be – what city wouldn't like to have a nationally renowned liberal arts college in its midst, one with which it has deep and extensive relationship?"

Under the heading "D. Strategy - Create exciting 'college-town' commercial corridors along Harrisburg Pike and College Avenue", John Fry speaks of development: "My hope is to work with the real estate development community to identify and eventually develop attractive, well-located sites for food, entertainment and cultural establishments along Harrisburg Pike and College Avenue. The area around the College should look and feel more like a 'college town', buzzing with activity at all hours of the day, a real magnet for people."

Fry continues, "College Avenue also provides a very interesting set of possibilities for commercial development. Unlike Harrisburg Pike, which must be tamed, calmed and re-scaled for pedestrians, College Avenue enjoys a wonderful scale, and with the right interventions (lighting, street furniture, trees) could have a terrific ambiance. Several properties might lend themselves to small scale retail uses (used bookstores, coffee houses), which would complement the larger developments along the Pike." (Question: Will College Ave., be rezoned to allow for these commercial establishments?)

Under "GOAL V - C. Strategy - Seek non-traditional sources of financial support: corporations, foundations, state and federal government, private ventures", he discusses the use of third-party investors: "To the extent we can demonstrate to developers that we have strong demand for residential, retail and other commercial amenities, and in some cases even own or control key pieces of real estate where these activities can occur, then we might be the beneficiaries of third-party investors willing to take on risk and invest with the College..."

Fry continues, "In all cases regarding commercial development, we must decide about the level of control we need to have in the venture ... the more control we wish, the more investment the College will be expected to make. This is the reality of doing business with private investors who are driven primarily by the need for a sufficient return on their capital."

Under "D. Strategy - Create a single, continuous campus with space to accommodate long-term growth and expansion", there is an obvious reference to the median strips (one of which has already been constructed): "We need more and better linkages to our holdings on the other side of the Pike. One of the major focal points of our upcoming campus physical planning study will be developing ways of forging friendlier and more pleasing connections between these two areas." (John Fry does not reveal that he has plans to remove the attractive overhead walkway at College Square that was built in 1991 specifically for the purpose of linking the two campuses. It was also designed to provide for pedestrian safety in crossing the Pike, which is a busy state highway.)

John Fry's intrusion into civic affairs and into the lives of citizens - who, unlike F&M, pay taxes - is unnerving. And he appears to be continually striving to expand his sphere of influence. Indeed, some residents are referring to him as "Mayor Fry," and one expression making the rounds is: "When John Fry says 'jump,' City officials jump." Because of this perception, many citizens are choosing to become inactive and silent on community affairs. This results in a loss of "brain power" of some of the City's best educated and most productive citizens - due to the undue influence of the president of a non-profit, multi-million dollar private corporation.

Lancaster City can and should stand free and proud on its own history and institutions and its officials can and should make decisions based on public - not private - interests. Citizens of Lancaster do not need to be dictated to by an overly-ambitious College president whose decisions are based on what's good for the College and who frequently disregards the stated wishes and opinions of the citizens of Lancaster.

Thursday, March 6, 2008

Rotary rash

I believe that NewsLanc's barring from the Rotary Club meetings is a validation of its work and a testament to NewsLanc's effectiveness. It is also disturbing.

NewsLanc has been the most sharply critical voice against the establishment for quite a while now, and, after months of regular attendance, out of the blue you are banned? No, NewsLanc is getting to them. I'd keep the pressure on. It was rash for Rotary to ban Matt Henderson, and stupid in my opinion

Monday, March 3, 2008

Thibault Campaign – "Empty Promises"

Did everyone get their [Paul] Thibault campaign mailer? Attached is an absentee ballot for a nice incentive to encourage votes on April 22. A campaign mailer full of empty promises.

"Cut Taxes Now" funny – he raised county taxes while in office.

"Reform State Government" has an interesting line - "too many decisions are made as a result of backroom deals, with no opportunity for public input" Thibault did that while a commissioner with one month left in office by making county taxpayers indebted to the tune of $40M bond for a pork barrel project.

"Stop the Spending Spree" – spending was something Thibault was quite good at while a Commissioner by building an overly large Youth Intervention Center and making the county taxpayers indebted with the CC/hotel.

Sunday, March 2, 2008

Debate over NewsLanc Letter in Sunday News

(Editor's Note: Letters are reproduced from a NewsLanc private list of concerned citizens)

Letter #1:

"We do believe that then-District Attorney Donald Totaro (who conducted a year long witch hunt), President Judge Louis Farina (who allowed Totaro to run amok), Lancaster Newspapers, and various members of a power elite tacitly acted together to politically destroy Shellenberger and Henderson due to their reservations about the convention center/hotel project." [Excerpt from NewsLanc's publisher Robert Edwin Field's "Letter to the Editor," Sunday News, March 2.]

That sounds so conspiratorial to me. This, I think, is what Marv Adams means when he says "NewsLanc" "sees a conspiracy at every turn." Who is this "we"? I'm curious as to whether there's anyone else who agrees with you on that... What do Totaro and Farina have to do with the convention center project? I mean I certainly agree that the Lancaster Newspapers go easy on their pet project in their coverage... but... I'm not so sure I buy this "power elite" everybody in bed with everybody else business.

I mean I understand what you're saying as far as... this Conestoga View business was an opportunity for Lancaster Newspapers to nail Henderson and Shellenberger if they had it out for them. Though Commissioners pleading guilty to violating the Sunshine Act is a big story... and it was perceived as very high-stakes because a lot of people were very passionate about Conestoga View... it was a big decision.

What you're doing is linking two (I think unconnected) (connected only in the sense that they are both unfavorable for opponents of the project) events - Lancaster Newspapers' investment in the project, and Totaro's investigation... by conjuring up this conspiracy... saying everyone must have been in on it. That's the step I have a hard time taking.


Letter #2 in Response:

[Former District Attorney Donald] Totaro empaneled his second grand jury - only the third in Lancaster County history - SUPPOSEDLY to investigate the hiring of one individual. Since when is this justification to seat a grand jury? It APPEARS the only reason this grand jury existed was to investigate the County Commissioners.

Why would ANYONE want to investigate the County Commissioners, especially with only the third Grand Jury in Lancaster County history? Because THEY DARED TO ASK QUESTIONS. At the time the grand jury was empaneled, the Lancaster Newspapers were already in full attack mode against Dick and Molly, who were asking questions about a project from which LNP stands to earn millions of dollars of profit on the investment of TAXPAYER dollars.

It gets even deeper: the grand jury was unable to substantiate the allegations of the improper hiring of that individual. So Totaro expanded their orders to include the sale of Conestoga View, including possible violations of the "Sunshine Act." When the grand jury found no violation of the law, Totaro threatened to charge the County Commissioners with violations of the "Sunshine Act" - even though he didn't have enough evidence to make the charges stick. They could have beaten the charges, but it would have cost each one of them over $100,000 and several years in court.

If Totaro was not in collusion with Lancaster Newspapers (or at least with the Establishment of Lancaster City and/or County), how can his illogical (some might say irrational) actions be explained?

Saturday, March 1, 2008

Why We Still Go to "Stupid Meetings"

You say, "Here we are today, still going to these stupid meetings, for what?"

Because it WILL hit the fan. It is inevitable. The project cannot possibly bring in more than a small fraction of the "economic development" that was promised to the public. And even if LNP tries to "spin" the truth by saying how much better Lancaster is because of the project, they won't be able to cover up the truth completely forever.

We all need to be prepared and ready for the inevitable. When it happens, we will then be able to speak knowledgeably about the issues.

And don't assume that those behind this will go unpunished. Depending on how hard and in what way the project falls, those who created this project could very well find themselves in the center of a LOT of attention.

Neglect of Southern End Will Close Down Center City After 5:00 PM

Ages ago my brother, an attorney, forewarned me that during the Convention Center Authority meetings, those in control DO NOT HAVE TO TALK, DEBATE OR ANSWER questions, they have the war won. I disagreed but guess what, he was right.

Here we are today, still going to these stupid meetings, for what? It is going to be built, it is going to be a cesspool of taxpayer dollars going into the pockets of the Haves. And the Middle Class taxpayer will be paying the tab as usual.

I will continue to ask questions in my own text but will never let the Powers forget what they have done. I will forever remember the meeting where Mike Sturla and Gib Armstrong were sitting behind me talking away and laughing at those at the microphone, their arrogant answer to me when I asked them to take their conversation in the hall so we could hear, Dale High telling me to get a life, these people will get their due.

Lancaster County will always support the City and we are fortunate to be getting the New Jersey and Philadelphia city goers to move into the City. My concern is the outlying southern end that will just get worse and hinder the possible nightlife of the Fulton or any possibility of future growth of nightlife. As time goes on safety after 5:00 PM will become a very big issue.

My goal is to continue to monitor the Commissioners. They may taken High money for campaign but they will get exposed. At a past meeting, Chris asked each one of them if they had accepted donations from High and all three admitted doing so. I believe that was the start.